Contractor vs. Employee in Remote Roles: What’s Right for You?
Summary:
Remote professionals often face a choice: work as a contractor or as a traditional employee. Contractors gain flexibility and higher earning potential but sacrifice benefits and stability. Employees trade some freedom for security and perks. The right choice depends on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and career stage.
Why This Question Matters in Remote Work
The remote revolution reshaped careers. But along with location freedom comes classification decisions that directly affect pay, taxes, and lifestyle.
Some thrive as contractors, chasing flexibility, gigs, and multiple income streams. Others prefer the employee path, valuing healthcare, retirement plans, and predictable paychecks.
Understanding the trade-offs helps you choose what’s right for your career.
The Core Differences
At the simplest level:
- Employees are hired directly by a company, with benefits and taxes withheld.
- Contractors (or freelancers) work independently, often juggling multiple clients, responsible for their own taxes and benefits.
Both models exist across remote-first companies—from startups to Fortune 500s.
Quick Comparison Table
| Factor | Contractor (Freelancer/Gig) | Employee (W-2/Full-time) |
|---|---|---|
| Flexibility | High – choose projects, schedule | Lower – tied to company hours/policies |
| Earnings | Potentially higher, variable | Stable, predictable salary |
| Taxes | Self-managed (use tools like TaxHub) | Employer withholds automatically |
| Benefits | None by default | Health, retirement, PTO (varies) |
| Job Security | Project-based, can end anytime | Longer-term, harder to terminate |
| Career Growth | Portfolio-driven, independent | Structured promotions, training |
| Tools & Expenses | Self-funded (may deduct costs) | Employer provides resources |
| Autonomy | High – choose clients | Lower – employer dictates work |
Pros of Being a Contractor
- Flexibility: Choose clients, projects, and working hours.
- Earnings potential: Rates can be higher per project, especially for niche skills.
- Multiple income streams: Diversify by working across industries.
- Entrepreneurial growth: Build your brand and portfolio on platforms like Fiverr.
Cons of Being a Contractor
- No benefits: Health insurance, retirement plans, and paid leave are self-funded.
- Tax complexity: Quarterly filings, self-employment tax, and expense tracking (a good reason to use TaxHub).
- Unstable income: Feast-or-famine cycles are common.
- Loneliness: Contractors often work without team structures.
Pros of Being an Employee
- Stability: Predictable paycheck and consistent hours.
- Benefits package: Health insurance, 401(k), parental leave, etc.
- Training & growth: Companies often invest in employee development.
- Team belonging: Access to culture, support, and collaboration.
Cons of Being an Employee
- Less flexibility: Limited control over hours, projects, or location.
- Earnings cap: Salaries grow slower compared to contractor rate jumps.
- Dependence: Your income is tied to one employer.
- Risk of burnout: Remote employees may struggle with blurred boundaries.
Lifestyle Fit: Which Path Suits You?
- Choose contracting if: You’re entrepreneurial, self-disciplined, and prefer freedom over structure. Tools like Avast can help contractors stay productive and secure while working independently.
- Choose employment if: You value stability, benefits, and career progression within an organization.
Some professionals even combine both paths—holding a traditional role while running side hustles. For examples, see our guide to Remote Side Hustles Launchable Immediately.
Taxes: The Deciding Factor for Many
One of the biggest differences is tax responsibility.
- Employees: Taxes are withheld automatically; you receive a W-2.
- Contractors: You handle your own filings, pay self-employment tax, and track deductions (home office, software, internet bills).
This makes tax planning critical for contractors. Services like TaxHub simplify compliance and help maximize deductions.
Is One “Better” Than the Other?
The short answer: it depends on you.
If you crave freedom and higher earning potential, contracting may be the right path. If you prefer security, healthcare, and stability, employment is likely the better fit.
🚀 FlexJobs Subscription
Curated remote job board with premium listings.
30% off for RWC readers – $29.95.
Get This Deal
🚀 Avast Premium Security
Security suite to keep your remote work devices protected.
Save up to 40% today – $39.99.
Get This Deal
🚀 NordVPN Subscription
VPN for secure remote work connections and privacy.
Up to 63% off annual plans – $59.88.
Get This Deal
Some remote workers transition between both over their careers: starting as contractors to build skills, then moving into employee roles for long-term security—or vice versa.
Contractor vs. Employee in Remote Roles FAQs:
Which is better for remote work: contractor or employee?
It depends. Contractors enjoy flexibility and higher potential earnings, while employees benefit from stability and perks like healthcare and PTO.
Do contractors pay more taxes than employees?
Yes. Contractors pay self-employment tax in addition to income tax, but they can deduct business expenses to reduce their liability.
Can you switch from contractor to employee (or vice versa)?
Yes. Many professionals start as contractors and later join companies as employees—or keep hybrid setups for balance.
Final Takeaway
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The contractor vs. employee choice in remote work comes down to lifestyle preferences, financial goals, and risk tolerance.
Think of it less as a permanent label and more as a career stage decision. The key is to align your work model with what matters most to you right now—and be open to shifting later.
Jedilyn Leyson turns operational chaos into executive leverage. With a sharp eye for hidden inefficiencies and a systems-first mindset, she helps founders and marketing teams convert overwhelm into organized execution. From untangling workflows to syncing cross-functional priorities, Jedilyn doesn’t just manage complexity—she turns it into a growth engine. Her superpower lies in spotting the invisible threads between people, processes, and performance—fueling campaigns that actually ship and strategies that scale.
View LinkedIn
